|
DarthDan Comment 1 As soon as life slows down enough for me to catch my breath, quaff this volume down, I will!
Angyll Comment 2 Awesome review hun! Sounds fantastic!
DARK LORD GRIEVOUS Comment 3 Good review Jeff.
Read it, I must. Darth Agnon Comment 4 This is so off base and absurd. What a poor and dissalusioned .. grrr, Are you kidding me? Wake up to the Star Wars coffee, this is the lamest sith ever! This series has been ruined by how quick they're trying to get rid of Caedus. Why spend so much time on such a weak sith? It's blasphemy to even call him a sith lord, compared with what we already know are "REAL" sith lords. I hope you enjoyed your paycheck for this article, because obviously that's all you did it for.
JediJef Comment 5 The only thing off-base and absurd is your clueless assertion that I write for money. The entire reason this site is here is to provide a forum for Star Wars fans to congregate and share honest opinions about the franchise, free from the constraints of the official forums, the sanitized community over at TFN, and other politically-correct sites. This site exists wholly separate from Lucasfilm or any other corporate interest, and if you'd been here for more than two days, you'd know that I take Lucas Licensing to task on a regular basis for the products that I consider subpar.
Legacy of the Force, however, is not one of them, particularly the writing of Karen Traviss, currently the finest author working in the morass that is the EU. I can excuse your poor taste, but I'd advise you to watch your mouth when you throw around accusations of payola, because you honestly don't have the faintest fucking idea what you're talking about.
Angyll Comment 6 Hmmm....if I were to choose between the opinions of someone whose are well thought out, articulated, and--albeit understandably biased towards his tastes--free from the choker of trying to please ANYONE with his opinions and does this just for his love of all things Star Wars, or someone who blasts theirs negatively with no actual support for his comments and shoves the "well my way is the only true way" attitude instead of fostering a discussion on the subject...
let's see here, I believe I will go with listening to the former. Definitely worth it. DarthDan Comment 7 QUOTE(Badreligion1276 @ March 7 2008, 03:35 AM) I hope you enjoyed your paycheck for this article, because obviously that's all you did it for. You really have some nerve coming in and throwing accusations like that. Jef, Dalamar, and myself haven't seen a dime for any of the hard work we've put into SWAC since October of 2005. Everything you see here is pure, unadulterated appreciation of Star Wars. What really irks me is the fact that last night you send me a personal message on MySpace talking about how you met up with a fan group and they were very snobby and you love and appreciate how we have created a place that is absent of that negativity. Then right after saying that to me, you come and falsely accuse Jef of taking a paycheck? WTF, man? QUOTE(Joshua from MySpace aka Badreligion1276) I was a member of the OSWCC ( Ohio Star Wars Collecting Club) briefly, mostly just online, But I attended thier Christmas Party one year and except for like 3 people, they were so snobby towards me. I was thinking, "Hey!, I'm one of you" but whatever so I stopped that nonsense, now to thier credit, they are state wide and do do alot of things community/charity ect wise, but for me to jump in and get the cold shoulder - I was very dissapointed But on your site, wow! mass instant love! hopefully some day I can the members of the universe we love that aren't snobs. thank you for having such a sight I wish Jef did get paid for his published work on SWAC. He certainly deserves it and the caliber of his writing speaks for itself. While you can feel free to disagree with the opinions that he (or anyone here) expresses, I'd be very kriffing careful of throwing around ungrounded and insulting accusations that serve as personal attacks to one of my staff or members. I won't tolerate it. It's not the atmosphere we're trying to create here, as your private message on MySpace lauded us for. JediJef Comment 8 Owned.
Seriously man, feel free to disagree and debate with me (if you think you're up to it), but have the sense to do a little fact-checking before you spout off. It just makes you look ignorant. DarthDan Comment 9 The thing that really disturbs me about this is the suggestion that Jef would sellout his candid opinions for a paycheck. While I have no doubt that he will eventually be paid professionally to write, you can rest assured that the Rantmaster will never sugarcoat a review in exchange for a kickback. Jef is one of the toughest critics I know and tells it like it is, from his point of view. On the rarity that he finds a product that he has no complaints with, Jef is loathe to publish an article without some point of criticism to keep from coming across as "gushy".
Additionally (and back to the subject matter that triggered Badreligion's initial polarizing comment), Jef speaks directly of Cadeus in one paragraph in the above review, applying more of his focus to Traviss' treatment of Boba Fett. bigox6942 Comment 10 Haven't gotten this far in TLoF books yet. I'm on book six. But I will admit that Traviss writes Boba so well, that I really am starting to like him.
I personally have hated Boba, and Jango, and all the other wanna be "Boba-Who's" since well, forever. Never got on the Boba-bandwagon. My logic was , how can you like a chararcter that had so few lines, was very cool looking, but yet dies like a little biotch in RotJ. And don't get me started on Darth Maul.... But Traviss has thought out very well, how Boba has grown up, and lived as the most feared Bounty Hunter in the galaxy. And how all in all he is just a man, er clone, that has had a tough life, and made a history for himself, and yet near the later part, his life catchs up with him. I so look forward to reading the rest of these books, and thanks for the great review. |
||